Analytics

Saturday, January 16, 2016

Miscellany: 1/16/16

Quote of the Day
Originality and the feeling of one's own dignity are achieved only through work and struggle.
Fyodor Dostoyevsky

Chart of the Day: "Progressive" Academia
via Daily Signal
Tweet of the Day
Image of the Day


A Teacher's Right to Work



Ideas That Changed the World

About the first video: both Boeing and Airbus have gotten government handouts, although Airbus much more so. From 2012:
U.S. planemaker Boeing received $5.3 billion in illegal government subsidies over a quarter-century, far less than what arch-rival Airbus received according to an earlier finding, the World Trade Organization ruled Monday.
I'm somewhat surprised on a series inspired by Friedman, they would feature a crony aircraft manufacturer (in fact, I misread the title, thinking they were talking about airbnb), but the real intent of the segment is to focus on division of labor.







Guest Post Comment: "Natural born in Canada"

This is all nonsense. First of all, both Canada and the US have birthright citizen (in fact, everywhere in the Americas except for one country). Birthright citizenship is actually in the context of English law, which both the US and Canada inherited. So Cruz, born in Canada, had dual citizenship, which is why he renounced his Canadian citizenship in 2014.

The US citizenship of Cruz is settled law. This also comes from English common law. "Natural born" was a commonly used term in 18th century English law--and is defined as inhabitant or offspring. Cruz' mother was indisputably born in the US. Even though it is true that Congress tweaked certain parameters involving age and/or residency over time (I think the reason the whole birther bullshit rose is solely because Obama's mother was 18--Barack would have been a US citizen, even if he was born in Kenya, if she had been in her 20's. The certified Hawaiian birth made the matter moot.), [under existing US law at the time Cruz' mother had the prescribed post-teen residency at the time of Cruz' birth]

The real purpose of the "natural born" criterion was to minimize the chance of foreign intrigue. If you have dual citizenship it could suggest divided loyalty. I do believe Trump has British citizenship by virtue of his mother's native Scottish birth, and I don't know if he's renounced it.

As for the Fourteenth Amendment and birthright citizenship, this is settled law. I believe I'm repeating myself from past posts: the exceptions listed to American-born citizenship have to do with the official status of the parents, e.g., diplomats or foreign troops on American soil. This is abundantly clear from context and numerous decisions since then.

Now you can, of course, find legal crackpots who will argue the opposite side of any legal dispute. I personally think that defining citizenship in terms of a native mother's residency is arbitrary and hence unconstitutional. Why, for example, would Barack Obama be a US citizen depending strictly on the age/residency after, say, the mother's age of 15? This flatly discriminates against the early children of any young American mother.

Instead of reading the nonsense of the Trump-supportive editors, consider the REAL legal scholars of the Volokh Conspiracy who have published several articles on the matter, the latest which is: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/ (Jan. 15/More scholars weigh in on whether Ted Cruz is a ‘natural born’ citizen)

The Trump Kids Video Backed By Hitler Youth Music



Facebook Corner

via Libertarian Catholic
What are your thoughts on Friedman's NIT, or any other form of basic income? Personally I think it's the perfect solution to issues like this, so long as its revenue isn't drawn from an income tax.
The issue with the negative income tax is moral hazard, just like for the welfare state. We should not be giving people an incentive not to be productive or to be less productive. It is better to let social welfare be handled by the private sector on a voluntary basis, e.g., charity, fraternal societies, etc.

There is, of course, a lot to be said about streamlining welfare programs, but I want a smaller State, not just a more efficient State.

How the Government Hobbles Charity



Political Cartoon
Courtesy of Glenn Foden via Townhall
Musical Interlude: My Favorite Vocalists

Gordon Lightfoot, "You Are What I Am"