Analytics

Sunday, June 4, 2017

Post #3241 M

Quote of the Day

Hatred is the most destructive force on earth. 
It does the most damage to those who harbor it.
Nido Qubein  


Tweet of the Day













Communications, Deregulation and Innovation




Mississippi and the Civil War

I came across this video via Newsalert (via nalrt.blogspot.com, which I would term more of a populist libertarian news portal). I, of course, reject the institution of slavery as evil and realize that the Southern aristocracy was intent on preserving its way of life.

A few takeaways here:

  • The Lincoln election had stoked regional fears, because Lincoln was elected without any Southern support. (In fact, he wasn't even listed on many Southern ballots). This exacerbated Southern fears of domination by a tyrannical Northeast-led majority.
  • We see the dependence of the Mississippi economy on King Cotton. Mississippi was heavily dependent on trade for food, preservatives like salt and other imports, and the war largely cut off trade and supplies. Given the law of comparative advantage, it was difficult to pivot to a more diversified, autarkic economy.
  • Whereas the slave-owner plutocracy did win secession in Mississippi, it was a closer fight than many realize. Not all white citizens benefited from slavery (as the clip points out slaves were used in other industries or lines of work, which dampened compensation), and many didn't want to open Pandora's box of secession. 
Overall, I think the video is better done than many conventional assessments of the "Civil War" (again, I am somewhat reluctant to use this term, because this war was not about the South trying to overthrow the federal government, but to separate from a hostile central government). I do think the video pays only passing lip service to defending one's homeland and briefly mentions the politically opportunistic, manipulative, cynical nature of Lincoln's Emancipation Proclamation, i.e., Lincoln felt the economy of the Confederacy was heavily dependent on the institution of slavery, and he hoped to stoke slave rebellions. He didn't have any relevant constitutional authority (recall the Fugitive Slave Laws were still on the books).



Political Cartoon

Courtesy of Eric Allie via Illinois Policy


Musical Interlude: My Favorite Vocalists


Neil Diamond, "And A Singer Sings His Song"